Charleston singles, we need to have a conversation. And some of you might not like where this is going.
As a dating coach and professional matchmaker, I've heard some pretty interesting explanations for why people won't date someone. Too short. Too tall. Doesn't make enough money. Wrong profession. Doesn't dress a certain way. Doesn't have the right social status. The list goes on.
But one woman said something that nearly took me out. She told me she couldn't take a man seriously if he drove a Subaru. A SUBARU.
Now, listen. I understand having preferences. Maybe you've always pictured yourself with a man who drives a nice luxury vehicle. Maybe a Subaru just doesn't do it for you. Fine. We all have our tastes. But dismissing an otherwise suitable partner because of the logo on his steering wheel? Ma'am, are we looking for a husband or shopping for a car?
And that's where I think some of us have gotten dating all the way confused. We've become so committed to finding someone who checks every box on our wish list that we're overlooking people who might actually be capable of building healthy, lasting relationships with us.
So let's talk about the difference between having standards and simply being picky.
Your Preferences Are Not Your Standards
Somewhere along the way, the word "standards" became a convenient umbrella for practically everything people want in a romantic partner.
He must be at least six feet tall. She must have a certain body type. He must make six figures. She must know how to cook. He needs a luxury vehicle. She needs to dress a certain way. He can't have this particular occupation. She can't have that particular hobby.
And when someone suggests being a little more flexible, the response is usually some variation of, "I'm not lowering my standards!"
But here's the thing: Not everything you want in a partner is a standard.
Standards are the expectations you establish regarding how someone treats you, the character they demonstrate, and the quality of relationship you're willing to participate in.
Preferences are the characteristics, qualities, or experiences you would ideally like someone to possess. They influence attraction and compatibility, but they aren't necessarily requirements for a healthy relationship.
Dealbreakers are the behaviors, circumstances, or incompatibilities that make a relationship unacceptable or unworkable for you.
These three categories aren't interchangeable.
Wanting a partner who is financially responsible? That's a reasonable standard. Requiring that person to earn a specific six-figure salary? That may be a preference or a genuine lifestyle compatibility requirement, depending on your circumstances.
Wanting someone you're physically attracted to? Absolutely reasonable. Insisting that attraction can only exist with someone who's exactly six feet tall? That's a preference.
Wanting someone who demonstrates integrity, emotional maturity, honesty, accountability, and respect? Now we're talking about standards.
And before somebody gets offended, you're allowed to have preferences. You're even allowed to decide which ones you're unwilling to compromise on. But let's stop calling every personal desire a relationship standard and pretending that all of them carry equal weight. Because they don't.
Looking Good on Paper Doesn't Mean Someone Is Good for You
Picture this, ladies.
You meet a man who's handsome, six-foot-two, financially successful, well-dressed, charismatic, and knows all the best restaurants in downtown Charleston. He has a beautiful home, takes great vacations, and knows exactly how to make a woman feel special.
On paper? He's everything you've been asking for.
Except he's entertaining several women while leading you to believe you're building something exclusive. He's inconsistent, emotionally unavailable, avoids difficult conversations, and disappears whenever things require vulnerability or accountability.
But hey, at least he's tall and has a nice watch.
Now, let's flip the script.
Men. You meet a beautiful woman with Southern charm, a great personality, a lovely smile, and enough social grace to make your mother adore her. She's the life of the party, looks amazing at every event, and even attends church on Sunday.
Except she's selfish, struggles to compromise, refuses to acknowledge when she's wrong, and withdraws affection whenever things don't go her way.
But she certainly looks good standing next to you at that oyster roast!
See the problem?
We sometimes give superficial qualities more importance than the very characteristics that determine whether a relationship can survive beyond the honeymoon phase. Physical attractiveness cannot compensate for emotional immaturity. Financial success doesn't automatically produce integrity. A charming personality doesn't guarantee kindness. And religious attendance, while potentially meaningful to someone seeking shared faith, doesn't automatically translate into healthy relationship behavior.
The qualities that initially attract you to someone aren't always the qualities that will sustain a relationship with them. And that is something that matters more than many singles realize.
The Person You're Overlooking Might Actually Be the Better Catch
Now, I'm not suggesting that singles should date people they find completely unattractive, ignore genuine incompatibilities, or force romantic connections that simply aren't there. Absolutely not.
But I am suggesting that some people need to examine how quickly they dismiss potentially compatible partners over things that have very little to do with relationship quality.
The man driving that Subaru might be financially disciplined, emotionally secure, generous, faithful, responsible, and genuinely interested in building a healthy partnership. Meanwhile, the man driving the luxury SUV you've been admiring might have you questioning your sanity by Thanksgiving.
The woman who doesn't turn every head when she enters a room might be thoughtful, affectionate, emotionally mature, supportive, and capable of building a beautiful life with someone. Meanwhile, the woman who gets everyone's attention might struggle to offer the mutual respect, consideration, and partnership a healthy relationship requires.
Of course, the reverse can also be true. Attractive, stylish, financially successful people can make wonderful partners, too. That's precisely the point.
You cannot accurately measure someone's relationship potential through superficial characteristics alone.
And when you use those characteristics as your primary screening criteria, you risk eliminating people before you've discovered who they actually are.
As a matchmaker, I believe attraction matters. Shared values matter. Lifestyle compatibility matters. But I also know that a successful match requires looking beyond the obvious. Sometimes the person who doesn't immediately fit your imagined picture may possess far more of what you actually need.
Some of Your Requirements Deserve a Second Look
Here's where a little self-awareness comes into play. When evaluating your dating expectations, it's worth asking yourself where some of them originated.
Are they rooted in your actual relationship needs? Your personal values? Your lifestyle? Or have they been shaped by social media, cultural expectations, past experiences, and what other people consider desirable? Because sometimes we're pursuing things we haven't even stopped to question.
Maybe you've convinced yourself that a man must earn a particular salary because you associate wealth with security. But is the deeper need financial stability, responsibility, ambition, or the ability to maintain a certain lifestyle?
Maybe you insist on dating only exceptionally attractive people because you genuinely need that level of physical attraction. Or perhaps being seen with an attractive partner gives you a sense of validation.
Maybe the woman you've always imagined marrying looks and behaves a certain way because that's what you've been taught makes a woman desirable. But have you considered the character, emotional skills, and shared values required to build the kind of marriage you actually want?
These aren't accusations. They're questions worth exploring. And sometimes our expectations are legitimate. A particular financial arrangement, religious conviction, family goal, or lifestyle difference may be deeply important to our compatibility. But other times, what we describe as nonnegotiable is simply something we've grown accustomed to wanting.
There's a difference between knowing what you need and refusing to examine what you want.
And While We're Discussing Standards, Can You Meet Your Own?
Oh, I couldn't leave this part out.
Because it's interesting how much energy some singles devote to evaluating potential partners without giving nearly as much attention to what they're bringing into a relationship.
You want emotional maturity, but how do you respond when someone disappoints you?
You want healthy communication, but do you shut down, lash out, or disappear when conversations become uncomfortable?
You want someone financially responsible, but are you practicing financial responsibility yourself?
You want honesty, loyalty, consistency, and accountability. Wonderful! But can the person dating you reasonably expect those same qualities in return?
Having standards doesn't mean you must be perfect before entering a relationship. Nobody is. It does, however, mean recognizing that healthy relationships require two people who are willing to demonstrate the qualities they expect from each other.
You cannot demand emotional availability while refusing vulnerability. You cannot expect accountability while constantly making excuses for your behavior. And you cannot build a mutually satisfying partnership if your entire dating philosophy revolves around what someone else must provide. Remember, it’s not about simply finding a good partner. You need to become one also.
Charleston, Date With Discernment, Not Just a Checklist
I know the dating landscape can be frustrating. Between dating apps, busy careers, shifting social expectations, and the challenges of meeting compatible people, singles have legitimate reasons to feel discouraged.
But I also believe some of that frustration could be reduced if we became more intentional about distinguishing what truly matters from what's merely nice to have.
That doesn't mean abandoning your desires or accepting relationships that don't meet your needs. It means getting clear about which qualities are essential to a healthy partnership and which ones might deserve a little flexibility.
Pay attention to how someone treats people when there's nothing to gain. Notice whether their words align with their actions. Observe how they manage disappointment, handle conflict, honor commitments, and demonstrate consideration for others.
Ask whether your values align. Whether your lifestyles are compatible. Whether you can communicate openly, respect one another, and work through differences without turning every disagreement into a battle.
And yes, make sure there's mutual attraction. Romance matters, too! But don't become so distracted by the packaging that you neglect to examine what's inside. Because a relationship isn't built on height, designer labels, Instagram aesthetics, or what somebody drives down King Street. It's built through character, consistency, compatibility, commitment, and two people willing to show up for one another.
And if you're fortunate enough to meet someone who offers those qualities, perhaps it's worth getting to know them before deciding their car isn't impressive enough.
After all, Charleston, you might discover that your next great love drives a Subaru. And wouldn't that be something?
Victoria "Coach Vee" Baxter is a Charleston-based dating and relationship coach, certified professional matchmaker, and founder of The New Love Collective. She helps singles navigate modern dating, recognize unhealthy relationship patterns, and build healthier, more intentional relationships.
