Early voting began October 19, and by November 3 Charleston County voters will decide whether to keep a half-cent sales tax for up to 25 years, or until it has collected $4.25 billion, whichever comes first.
Question 1 continues the half-cent first approved in 2004, so the rate would not go up. It sets $2.702 billion for roads, $858 million for transit, and $690 million for the Greenbelt. Question 2 would let the county issue up to $300 million in bonds, paid from the same tax. The county's program sheet counts $284.1 million in debt service inside the roads share.
Start with the record, because a 25-year promise is only as good as the last two. The county sent me its current numbers for its big "featured" projects. For the 2004 tax, 21 of 22 are complete, and the last is being advertised or awarded. For the 2016 tax, now ten years old, three of 12 are complete, three are under construction, one is being advertised or awarded, and five are still in design or permitting.
Costs and opposition played a part. Highway 41 in Mount Pleasant was estimated at about $129 million in 2016 and is now $245 million, which the county attributes largely to inflation and the pandemic. The first segment of the Main Road project on Johns Island has gone from roughly $130 million to $445 million, and two other pieces of that plan were dropped or put on hold, one after public opposition. Reporting also says the county spent the 2016 tax as it was collected, which slowed the big projects.
Then there is the Mark Clark Extension of I-526. It was not on the 2004 or 2016 project lists. Critics, including the Post and Courier editorial board, say voters were assured in 2016 that the tax would not pay for it, and that the county broke that assurance by committing $75 million of the tax to keep planning it. None of that was spent. By the latest accounting I found, about $58 million was spent on the extension over the years, most of it state money to buy land along the route. The price grew from $420 million in 2006 to $2.3 billion, county voters rejected a tax meant mainly to pay for it, 61 to 39, in 2024, and the state ended the project in May 2025.
That is a mixed record. The county delivered nearly all of its big 2004 projects and a quarter of its big 2016 projects. Both facts belong in your decision.
So how would we know the next promise is kept? In June, County Council changed the ballot from projects that "may include" the listed ones to projects "that include" them, and added that if a project cannot be done, its money goes to another listed project. But the ballot also lists "other future needs for highways, roads, streets, bridges, and drainage facilities." The list is specific, and it is open at the edges.
I am not telling you how to vote. Supporters say there is no realistic replacement for this money except higher property taxes. Skeptics ask why a county with this record should be trusted for 25 more years. Read the ballot language and the project list at charlestontransportation.com, and ask three questions. Who can change the list after the vote, and by what vote? Who checks the spending, and where is that report published? Do the listed projects match what your neighborhood and the whole county need? And check candidates the same way. Look at the record, not just the promise.
A harbor is shared water. A sailboat, a shrimp boat, and a container ship all use the same channel, and none of them is trying to beat the others. Vote like a member of that crew, and ask what your vote does for the whole harbor, not just your own boat. Then, when the votes are counted, get back to work together.
Ernie Patterson lives on James Island and at Carolina Trace in Lee County, N.C. He writes Just Some Thoughts @efpatterson.substack.com
